Florida Hurricane Damage Supplemental Claims – The Need to Comply With Conditions Under the Policy

It is Hurricane season, and many South Florida Homeowners may sustain some form of damage to their residences.  When this occurs, it is very important to immediately contact your insurance company in order to comply with conditions precedent under your policy.  Reason being, the insurance carriers will deny coverage under the policy if you fail to notify them within a certain amount of time of the damage (typically 60 days), and they may ask you to sit for an examination under oath (EUO) in order to get some additional support and factual information to support your claim.  When an insured fails to comply with the policy provisions, a wind, flood or homeowners insurance carrier will refuse to make payments under the policy, and these may actually be legitimate reasons to deny coverage.

This situation was apparent in the case of Edwards v. State Farm Florida Ins. Co., 64 So.3d 730 (Fla. 3d DCA 2011), where a homeowner sustained roof damage to their residence arising out of Hurricane Frances, one of the major storms of 2004.  Because the damage was within the homeowner’s deductible, State Farm, although admitting coverage, did not make any payment under the policy.  Thereafter, four years later, the homeowner made a supplemental insurance claim via a public adjuster, claiming additional damage as a result of Hurricane Frances.  When State Farm repeatedly requested that the homeowner provide documentation of the claimed loss and submit to an examination under oath, these requests were not complied with.  The insured never submitted to an EUO, nor did he provide sufficient documentation for State Farm to evaluate the supplemental claim.  The insured apparently retained a Miami Hurricane damage insurance dispute lawyer that handles supplemental claims, given that he filed suit for breach of contract after failing to receive benefits under his policy.  The trial court granted summary judgment to State Farm, finding that the policy requirements to submit to an examination under oath (if requested, and must be at a mutually convenient place and time), as well as submit documents that accurately reflect the amount of loss claimed, were conditions precedent that the insured failed to comply with, thus relieving the insurer of its duty to make payments under the policy.  The Third District Court of Appeal affirmed the trial court’s ruling.

Moral of the Story:  Whether you are a homeowner that lives in Hollywood, Dania, Weston, Homestead, Plantation, Aventura, Miami Beach, Bal Harbour, Tamarac, Kendall, Boca Raton or another area within Miami, Fort Lauderdale or Palm Beach, if you sustain roof or other types of damage to your home due to a Hurricane, flood or windstorm, make sure you comply with the various requests of your insurance carrier which may be conditions precedent to securing benefits under the policy.  These requests could be the ones at issue in the case above, namely, a request to sit for an examination under oath, or a request for supportive documentation.  A homeowner should actually consult with a Hurricane damage insurance claim lawyer to make sure these policy provisions are complied with, thereby reducing the chance of coverage issues being raised.

Speak Your Mind